Moving to Windermere, Florida means choosing between two quite different sides of the same lake town. West Windermere puts you near Windermere Village, Winter Garden and newer gated neighborhoods, while East Windermere sits closer to the Butler Chain of Lakes, the historic town center and the golf clubs of Isleworth and Bay Hill. Before you tour a single house, I ask my clients which daily routine they want, because that answer usually picks the side for them.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7VVhm6mmws
I walk through both sides in the video above. Below is the written version: how the two halves compare, where people eat and shop, what the schools look like on paper, and the questions buyers ask me most often once they start looking seriously. For the bigger picture of neighborhoods and listings, my Windermere community guide is the place to start.

How do East and West Windermere compare?
People often talk about Windermere as one place, but the address covers the small incorporated town plus a wide stretch of unincorporated southwest Orange County. In practice, the conversation I have with buyers splits it into an east side and a west side. Neither is better. They simply suit different habits.
| Feature | West Windermere | East Windermere |
|---|---|---|
| Shopping and dining hub | Windermere Village and the Westside Shops | The Grove, plus the historic town center |
| Nearby towns | Winter Garden and Clermont | Dr. Phillips and the Bay Hill area |
| Housing style | Many newer homes inside gated communities | Established neighborhoods, fewer large gated developments |
| Lake access | Surrounded by lakes used for fishing, wakeboarding and paddleboarding | Deeded Butler Chain access in many neighborhoods |
| Golf | Short drive to the east side clubs | Isleworth Golf & Country Club, the Golden Bear Club at Keene's Pointe, Arnold Palmer's Bay Hill |
| Schools on this side | Windermere High School and Windermere Prep | Served by OCPS zones that vary by street |
| Main trade-off | Rush hour backups on the roads that loop the lakes | Fewer of the newest luxury gated options |
What is West Windermere like?
The west side is where most of the newer construction and gated neighborhoods sit. Windermere Village and the Westside Shops cover groceries, coffee and dinner without a long drive, and Winter Garden and Clermont are close enough for everything else. Two of the best known schools in the area are here too: Windermere High School, which is public, and Windermere Prep, which is private.
Lakes ring much of this side, so fishing, wakeboarding and paddleboarding are part of normal weekends rather than special trips. The honest downside is traffic. The main roads that wind around the lakes get crowded at peak hours, and a commute that looks like 20 minutes on a map can run longer. I always suggest driving your work route at 7:45 a.m. before you write an offer.
What is East Windermere like?
East Windermere has more of a small town character. Restaurants, shops and recreation facilities are close by, and The Grove adds more dining and shopping a few minutes away. Many homes here come with deeded rights to reach the Butler Chain of Lakes, and the town provides tennis and basketball courts and hosts a farmers market every Friday.
This is also golf country. Isleworth Golf & Country Club, the Golden Bear Club in Keene's Pointe and Arnold Palmer's Bay Hill Club are all within a short drive. If you want to live inside one of these clubs, my Isleworth community page covers the guard-gated option. The trade-off on the east side is that it has fewer of the large, newer luxury gated communities you will find to the west.
What is there to do outside in Windermere?
Water is the center of life here. Most local sources count about 13 lakes in the Butler Chain, linked by canals, so a boat can move from lake to lake without ever touching a road. Fishing, wakeboarding and paddleboarding are everyday activities, and many of my clients plan their search around whether a home has a dock or deeded lake access.
- Parks and trails: local parks and nature preserves offer hiking and biking trails, picnic spots and playgrounds.
- Town events: Windermere runs community events through the year, which is how many newcomers meet their neighbors.
- Golf: three well known clubs (Isleworth, the Golden Bear Club and Bay Hill) sit within a few miles of each other.
Which schools serve Windermere?
School options cover both public and private routes. Windermere High School holds an overall A+ grade on Niche, and in August 2025 U.S. News ranked it 65th in Florida and 4th in Orange County, as reported by the Orange Observer. It is known for strong academics and a wide range of extracurricular programs.
Windermere Prep is the main private alternative, and Niche lists it as the top private high school in Orange County. Schools here put real weight on community involvement, so parents tend to be active participants. Zoning for public schools changes by street, so always confirm the assigned school with Orange County Public Schools for the exact address before you buy.
Where do people eat and shop in Windermere?
Restaurants
The dining scene runs from casual to fine dining. A few names come up again and again when I ask clients where they ended up on a Friday night:
- Agave Azul: the Mexican spot locals return to, located in Windermere Village.
- Clean Juice: organic juices, smoothies and lighter snacks.
- Gators and Greek restaurants: for a broader menu and something different from the usual.
Shopping
- Windermere Village: a central cluster of stores and restaurants on the west side.
- Local markets: farmers markets and specialty shops sell fresh produce and goods you will not find in a chain store.
Why does the farmers market matter so much?
For me, the clearest picture of Windermere is a Friday morning downtown. According to the Town of Windermere, the market runs every Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. along Town Square Park on Main Street, weather permitting. It is where you see how the community comes together, and it is a big part of why so many people tell me the town feels like home almost as soon as they arrive. I wrote more about it in my farmers market guide, and you can see it in the video below.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fMdEDO_ZTyQ
How should you decide where to live in Windermere?
Start with three questions. What does your weekday look like, and which roads will you drive at rush hour? Which amenities do you actually use: a dock, a golf membership, a walkable shop or restaurant? And what schooling do you need, public or private? Your answers usually point clearly to the west or the east side. If you are coming from another city or state, my relocation services page explains how I help clients plan a move from a distance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is West Windermere or East Windermere better for a move?
Neither is better overall. West Windermere has more newer gated neighborhoods, Windermere Village and quick access to Winter Garden and Clermont, but the lake roads get congested at rush hour. East Windermere is closer to the Butler Chain, the historic town and the Isleworth and Bay Hill golf clubs, with fewer new luxury gated options. Your commute and daily habits should decide.
How many lakes are in the Butler Chain of Lakes?
Most local sources count about 13 interconnected lakes, though some references list 11 depending on how smaller lakes are grouped. The lakes are linked by canals, so boaters can travel between them. Many Windermere neighborhoods include deeded access, but rules vary by community, so I check the access terms for every property my clients consider on the chain.
When is the Windermere Farmers Market?
The Town of Windermere lists the farmers market every Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 1:30 p.m., weather permitting. It sets up along Town Square Park on Main Street in the historic town center. It is one of the easiest ways for a newcomer to get a feel for the town and meet people who live there.
What schools are in Windermere, Florida?
Windermere High School is the best known public option, with an A+ overall grade on Niche and a 2025 U.S. News ranking of 4th in Orange County. Windermere Prep is the leading private school. Public school assignments depend on the exact address, so confirm zoning with Orange County Public Schools before you sign a contract.
Which golf clubs are near Windermere?
Three clubs sit close together on the east side: Isleworth Golf & Country Club, the Golden Bear Club at Keene's Pointe, a Jack Nicklaus design, and Arnold Palmer's Bay Hill Club & Lodge. Membership types and costs differ by club, so contact each one directly for current terms before you pick a neighborhood around a membership.
Ready to look at Windermere in person?
If you are weighing a move to Windermere, I would be glad to show you both sides of town and help you match a neighborhood to the way you live. I am Tiffany Pantozzi with ALIGN Real Estate. Call me at 689.215.6836 or send me a message and we can plan your first tour.

